
The U.S. government has invested billions of dollars in efforts to reduce reliance on China for rare earth processing, yet progress has been slow. MP Materials was awarded over $1 billion in funding, while USA Rare Earth secured a $1.6 billion package. Still, China dominates roughly 90% of global rare earth processing, supplying nearly all the dysprosium and terbium used in American weapons systems. Despite the financial support, the country has failed to build the necessary processing capacity.
Now, the Army is exploring a different strategy. On November 3, it signed a nonbinding agreement with REalloys (Nasdaq: ALOY) to develop heavy rare earth processing at Tooele Army Depot in Utah. The arrangement covers 200 acres, with a potential 75-year lease and a right of first refusal on production. Unlike previous initiatives, this model relies on private investment—REalloys will finance and construct the facility, while the Army provides land and security. The Army will only collect rent once commercial operations begin, eliminating taxpayer risk entirely.
Jeff Waksman, the Army’s principal deputy assistant secretary for installations, energy, and environment, described the approach as a way to expand critical minerals production without exposing taxpayer funds to risk. The key innovation is replacing subsidies with guarantees of permanence, proximity, and priority access to production.
China’s Processing Monopoly and Lost Expertise
The core challenge lies not in mining but in processing. China established its dominance in the 1980s through state subsidies, lenient environmental standards, and low labor costs. North American processing plants closed, expertise vanished, and the specialized knowledge required to refine rare earths into defense-grade materials disappeared. While funding can support mining or separation plants, the metallization step—converting oxides into high-purity metals—demands decades of hands-on experience. This expertise gap has derailed most government-backed projects.
Its Euclid, Ohio facility has worked with the Pentagon, NASA, and the Department of Energy. In March, the company secured a Defense Logistics Agency contract for modular metallization technology. REalloys also holds an 80% offtake agreement on production from the Saskatchewan Research Council’s rare earth facility, which was designed without Chinese technology. That plant is targeting 525 tonnes of neodymium-praseodymium metal annually by Q1 2027, along with 30 tonnes of dysprosium oxide and 15 tonnes of terbium oxide.
The urgency stems from a Pentagon rule effective January 1, 2027, banning Chinese-origin rare earths in weapons systems. Beijing’s temporary suspension of export controls on seven heavy rare earths expires on January 10, 2027, raising concerns about further supply constraints. REalloys is already qualifying defense-grade materials ahead of the deadline, with high-purity outputs expected as early as Q4 2026.
Related Post: U.S. Army leases depot for rare earth magnet production
Army’s Land-for-Permanence Model Avoids Subsidy Risks
If the Tooele model succeeds, it could serve as a blueprint: the government provides land and security, while private firms handle capital and technical expertise. The Army’s first right to production ensures demand, but the project must be economically viable on its own, a discipline previous subsidies often lacked.
Other companies are also racing against the same deadline. Evolution Metals & Technologies (Nasdaq: EMAT) is expanding its South Korean plant to produce over 10,000 metric tons of magnets annually, aiming for revenue of $400 million to $460 million by 2027. However, its success depends on unsecured demand, and the company has listed its ability to continue as a going concern among key risks.
REalloys’ leadership team strengthens its defense connections. The company’s advisory board includes former Secretary of Defense Chief of Staff Joe Kasper and retired four-star General Jack Keane, both with deep military logistics experience. Chairman Stephen S. DuMont, President of GM Defense, brings automotive and aerospace supply chain expertise. These relationships suggest REalloys can handle Pentagon procurement more effectively than many rivals. The company’s $100 million private placement in June 2026 further bolstered its financial position, entering the Tooele project with $122.4 million in cash and virtually no debt.
Cost Overruns and Why Traditional Funding Fails
Financial realities in the broader rare earth sector show the challenges of scaling up. Lithium Americas’ Thacker Pass project, backed by federal loans, saw its Phase 1 capital estimate rise to $3.83 billion from $2.93 billion in November 2026, citing labor costs, tariffs, and unforeseen expenses. The company expects to cover a $995 million funding gap using its own capital and Department of Energy reserves. Such cost increases highlight why the Army’s land-for-permanence model may be more sustainable than traditional subsidies; it removes the need to justify every dollar spent to taxpayers.
Albemarle’s third-quarter results provide a contrasting perspective. The lithium processor reported $1.55 billion in net sales and $646 million in adjusted EBITDA, driven by strong lithium prices. Even established players face volatility, however: the company reduced its 2026 capital spending guidance to $300 million–$350 million from $500 million, reflecting market fluctuations. For rare earths, where demand is tied to defense contracts rather than commodity cycles, the Army’s model may offer the stability lacking in other sectors.
Leave a Reply